top of page
Search

When Was Peter Saved?

Jan 26
4 min read


 For all who are led by the Spirit of God are children of God. (Romans 8:14 NLT).


I like to play the devil’s advocate. What I mean is, I love to ask provocative questions that force people to face up to the inconsistencies and absurdities of what they claim to believe. My “gift” for causing trouble may make some question my ordination, but I find comfort in the fact that Jesus loved to ask loaded questions too (see Mk. 11:27-33; 12:35-36; etc.). So, I guess you could say that I’m just trying to be like him. Let me give you an example of what I’m talking about.


I love to ask Christians the question: When was Peter saved? Most people have never thought about this, but the question sounds easy enough, so they are happy to respond. Typically, the answers fall into one of four categories.


  • Some believe Peter was saved the day he heard Jesus say, “Follow me.” When he put his trust in Jesus and left everything in obedience to the call, he was saved.


  • Others claim Peter’s salvation occurred when he confessed that Jesus was the Messiah, the Son of God. Obviously, he couldn’t be saved if he didn’t know who Jesus was. Right?


  • Others insist that Peter was saved on Easter morning, when he realized that Jesus’ death had paid the penalty for his sins. Salvation occurred when his sins were forgiven.


  • Still others say that Peter’s salvation took place on the day of Pentecost, when he was filled with the Holy Spirit and his heart was transformed by God’s grace.


I love the way this simple question compels people to expose what they really believe about the gospel and the salvation it promises. Answering it reveals more about the person I’m talking to than it does about Peter’s salvation! In fact, honest reflection on this question can cause a transformation in one’s theology as well as in one’s practice of Christian discipleship.

So, when was Peter saved? The tricky part of my question is in the way it is formulated. If I had asked, “When was Peter called to be a disciple?” or “When did Peter first confess that Jesus is Lord?” or “When did Peter experience forgiveness?” or “When was Peter filled with the Spirit?” most of us would know the answer immediately. But in asking when Peter “got saved,” my question was mischievously designed to cause trouble and provoke conflict. And yet this is precisely the way American evangelicals prefer to frame the question! Go figure.


The American church tends to equate “the gospel” with “the plan of salvation.” The emphasis is on the steps one needs to follow in order to experience salvation, which is understood almost completely in terms of receiving forgiveness and going to heaven. This often results in an understanding of salvation that is formulaic and ritualistic: admit your need, raise your hand, come forward, pray the prayer…. Presto, you just “got saved.”


It is not my intent to make fun of those who think of salvation in terms of following a prescribed recipe. Indeed, for most of my life that is how I understood what the gospel was all about. My purpose here is simply to point out that Peter’s salvation does not fit the pattern we are so enamored with in the church today. The truth is that our Americanized methodology for preaching the gospel and urging people to “get saved” is hard to find in the New Testament at all!


It is sobering to realize that the church is full of people who testify to being “saved” but have little comprehension of what it means to repent of sin, to surrender to Jesus as Lord, or to be filled with the Holy Spirit. Churches today are efficient in producing converts, but are often incompetent when it comes to making disciples. Dealing with a similar situation in Germany nearly a century ago, Dietrich Bonhoeffer put it this way: “Christianity without discipleship is always Christianity without Christ” (Cost of Discipleship, p. 59).


The story of Peter reminds us that the gospel is about so much more than ensuring that we can go to heaven when we die. Jesus came to make disciples. He came as King and Lord, not just Savior. To pretend that we can claim salvation while continuing to conform our lives to the patterns of this world is to misunderstand the gospel at its very core. To preach a gospel that omits the sovereign lordship of Jesus over all of creation is to preach a gospel that is no gospel at all. A pastor who allows his people to think they can be “saved” without bowing in submission to King Jesus is guilty of pastoral malpractice of the worst kind.


It would be impossible to find a better summary of what the gospel actually is than to examine the sermon preached by Peter himself on the day of Pentecost (see Acts 2:22-36). His message is not focused on the steps one needs to take in order to “get saved.” Rather, his passion is to proclaim the life, death, resurrection, and ascension of Jesus. Rather than closing his sermon with an invitation, asking people to raise their hands and come forward if they wanted to be saved, he concludes his message by boldly proclaiming the essence of the gospel: “Let all the house of Israel therefore know for certain that God has made him both Lord and Christ, this Jesus whom you crucified” (Acts 2:36).


Although Peter’s sermon is finished, no one moves. A spirit of conviction has fallen on the congregation as they recognize their own treasonous rebellion against King Jesus. In unison, they cry out, “What should we do?” (Acts 2:37). The question is Peter’s cue to explain the appropriate way to respond when the gospel is preached.


And Peter said to them,“Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit…And with many other words he bore witness and continued to exhort them, saying, 'Save yourselves from this crooked generation’” (Acts 2:38-40).


The gospel you preach determines the disciple you get.



 
 
 

5 Comments


Jennifer
Jan 31

Thank you for your message. You’re insight is thought provoking. I love how you cause me to pause and consider your thoughts. Our desire to see others gets saved can cause us to, at times, focus on a process and not wait upon the Holy Spirit to do the convicting. There must always be the concept of our sin and need of repentance for one to truly understand the Gospel and come to be born again. Discipleship is so important.

Like

Rob Congdon
Jan 29

As a doctor who's delivered 1000's of babies, I find Jesus' straightforward statement to Nicodemus very compelling: "Unless a man is born again, he will not see the Kingdom of God"! In truth, this is far more commonly heard on the lips of churchgoers in Africa, than here in the modern American church. Being born into the world, as Jesus knew by His own creative genius and by His incarnation experience, is a miraculous and dramatically-instantaneous event. I love you, Stan, but I think your 'devil's advocacy' is unhelpful here. After babies are born, let us celebrate their life, feed them, and urge them to 'grow in grace and in the knowledge of our Lord and Savior'.

Like

Lea
Jan 28

Have never doubted your ordination. I have been blessed, challenged, and comforted by your ministry to me these 40+ years. You lead us to consider…..

Like

Dave
Jan 27

Extremely thought provoking! Much needed for whole church! Thank You

Like
Bob Kanary
Jan 27
Replying to

I like the question. My neighbor's high school son, helped me shovel snow yesterday. He came in for a cup of hot tea afterward. We talked about the things of the Lord. He said he needed Christ in his life. He was reverent and humble.

I would say that he came to Jesus.

I'm also thinking of our Wesleyan, pathway of grace, prevenient, etc.


A lot of follow-up begins here...

Edited
Like

ONEWAY IS A FAMILY OF MISSIONS AND MEDIA MINISTRIES

MNN-circle-white.png
Prayercast-circle-white.png
OWS-circle-white.png
OWA-circle-white.png
HBN-circle-white.png
OWYA-circle-white.png
SLW-circle-white.png
DE-circle-white.png

owm.org

630.626.4990
mail@owm.org

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Vimeo
  • Youtube

© 2025 OneWay Ministries

Screen Shot 2025-07-09 at 3.23.33 PM.png
bottom of page